Sourcing criteria, screening questions and evaluation criteria
The three ways a candidate is measured, one for each moment of the process, and why they aren't the same.
In Spanish: Criterios de sourcing, Preguntas de screening and Criterios de evaluación.
What it is
A job post measures its candidates three times, each with its own rule. They look alike, but they measure different things with different evidence, and mixing them up is the costliest mistake.
| Sourcing criteria | Screening questions | Evaluation criteria | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it asks | Is it worth reaching out? | Do they meet the minimums only they can confirm? | Are they who the client needs? |
| With what evidence | Their profile | What the candidate answers | The interviews |
| When | While searching, before the pipeline | When they apply, or in a screening interview | After each interview |
| How it's measured | Good fit, Fit, Bad fit or No data | Pass or Fail | A score from 1 to 5 |
| Do they weigh? | Yes: order is weight | No | Yes: High, Medium or Low |
| Do they disqualify? | If they're must-haves | If they're must-haves, which only a required question can be, and never a free-text one | Never |
| What they produce | The longlist and the Match score | Who moves on to interview | The scorecard |
What it's for
| What for | |
|---|---|
| Sourcing criteria | Ranking who's worth writing to, among hundreds of profiles that haven't talked to you yet |
| Screening questions | Settling cheaply what no profile says: work permit, expected salary, when they can start |
| Evaluation criteria | Putting in writing, after the interview, how good they are for the role. It's what the client reads in the report |
Where you see it
| Set up in | The result shows in | |
|---|---|---|
| Sourcing criteria | Sourcing, Criteria block, or Edit job post | The longlist, and the candidate's Match score tab |
| Screening questions | Step 3 of the wizard, or the job post settings | Your careers page form, and the Match score tab |
| Evaluation criteria | Step 5 of the wizard, or the job post settings | The candidate's Evaluation tab, and the report |
What it gets mixed up with
| Mixed up with | The difference |
|---|---|
| The job post's requirements | Requirements, required and nice to have, are what applicants read on the role. Criteria are what we measure them with. Reclee proposes criteria by reading the requirements, but they aren't the same |
| The ideal profile | It says where to look, but doesn't score. Putting something in the ideal profile doesn't make it count: only criteria count |
| Must-have and weight | Two separate things. Weight comes from order, and the must-have mark goes on any position |
Why it works this way
There are three because the evidence is different. The profile is read and inferred from, the candidate declares, and the interview observes. Screening is the only moment the candidate speaks, which is why it's where whatever the profile left as No data gets settled, without spending an hour of interview.
In sourcing, order is weight, not a separate number. That way no weight contradicts the priority, and reordering is the only way to change it. The split is fixed: adding a criterion doesn't change the meaning of the ones already there.
Must-have is separate because some low-weight requirements are still mandatory: a work permit can sit in fifth place and disqualify whoever lacks it. Moving it up so it disqualifies would distort the order of the rest.
A free-text question is never a must-have because its answer is read, not compared. What disqualifies on its own has to be checkable without interpreting. And an optional question can't be a must-have, because whoever skips it would have nothing to fail.
Evaluation criteria never disqualify: they're a judgment after the interview, and they only weigh. Whatever doesn't meet a minimum is settled earlier, in sourcing or in screening.
How it's calculated
A sourcing criterion's weight comes from its position: the first is worth three times the last, and together they add up to 100%.
| With 5 criteria | With 10 criteria |
|---|---|
| 30% · 25% · 20% · 15% · 10% | 15% · 13.9% · 12.8% · 11.7% · 10.6% · 9.4% · 8.3% · 7.2% · 6.1% · 5% |
None goes below 5%, and you can have up to 10. How they combine into a score is in Match score. The evaluation weights, High, Medium and Low, are in Scorecard. Screening questions have no calculation: each one passes or fails.